Doctors confirm 200-year-old diagnosis


Doctors have confirmed a diagnosis made more than 200 years ago by one of medicine’s most influential surgeons.

John Hunter had diagnosed a patient in 1786 with a “tumour as hard as bone”.

Royal Marsden Hospital doctors analysed patient samples and case notes, which were preserved at the museum named after him – the Hunterian in London.

As well as confirming the diagnosis, the cancer team believe Mr Hunter’s centuries-old samples may give clues as to how cancer is changing over time.

“It started out as a bit of fun exploration, but we were amazed by John Hunter’s insight,” Dr Christina Messiou told the BBC News website.

Mr Hunter became surgeon to King George III in 1776 and is one of the surgeons credited with moving the medical discipline from butchery to a science.

He’s also rumoured to have given himself gonorrhoea as an experiment while writing a book about venereal diseases.

His huge medical collection is now housed at the Hunterian Museum at the Royal College of Surgeons.

It includes his colourful notes describing a man who arrived at St George’s Hospital, in 1786, with a hard swelling on his lower thigh.

“It appeared to be a thickening of the bone, it was increasing very rapidly… On examining the diseased part, it was found to consist of a substance surrounding the lower part of the thigh bone, of the tumour kind, which seemed to originate from the bone itself.”

Mr Hunter amputated the man’s leg and he recovered briefly for four weeks.

“From this time he began to lose flesh and sink gradually, his breathing more and more difficult,” the notes continued.

The patient died seven weeks after the operation and an autopsy discovered bony tumours had spread to his lungs, the lining of the heart and on the ribs.

Bony growths had spread to the patient’s lungs


More than 200 years later, the samples fell under the gaze of Dr Christina Messiou.

She said: “Just looking at the specimens, the diagnosis of osteosarcoma came very quickly to me and John Hunter’s write up was amazingly astute and fits with what we know about the behaviour of the disease.

“The large volumes of new bone formation and the appearance of the primary tumour are really characteristic of osteosarcoma.”

She went to get a second opinion from her colleagues at the Royal Marsden in central London.

And in an out-of-hours session at the hospital they used modern day scanning technology to confirm the centuries old diagnosis.


Dr Messiou, whose speciality is sarcoma, told the BBC: “I think his diagnosis is really impressive and in fact his management of the patient followed similar principles to what we would have done in the modern day.”

But she says the exciting stage of the research is still to come.

They are now going to compare more of Hunter’s historical samples with contemporary tumours – both microscopically and genetically – to see if there are any differences.

Dr Messiou told the BBC: “It’s a study of cancer evolution over 200 years and if we’re honest we don’t really know what we’re going to find.

“But it would be interesting to see if we can link lifestyle risk factors with any differences that we see between historical and current cancers.

“So we’ve got big ambitions for the specimens.”

Writing in the British Medical Journal, the Royal Marsden team apologised for delay in analysing the samples from 1786 and the obvious breach of cancer waiting times, but point out their hospital was not built until 1851.




Follow James  on Twitter.





Credit: BBC News Health.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.